Read in:
English
Death
The axis: death as an exercise of freedom, an examination of meaning, a pose to
be unmasked — or a question that need not be answered.
Learning to die: death sets free
- Montaigne (
montaigne) — to philosophize is to learn to die: he who has thought death through is free, and the loss of life ceases to be an evil. Grounding:nauchitsya-umirat,uchis-umirat-chtoby-byt-svobodnym,uchitsya-umirat-uchitsya-zhit. - Epictetus (
epictetus) — keep death before your eyes daily: the anticipation of death kills base thoughts and excessive desires. Grounding:predvarenie-smerti,razlichay-podvlastnoe.
Death as an examination of meaning
- Tolstoy (
tolstoy) — death destroys every finite meaning: only a meaning that death does not destroy will do; otherwise there are four means of escape, the noose among them. Grounding:smert,smysl-kotory-ne-unichtozhaet-smert,chetyre-vykhoda. - Pascal (
pascal) — man is a reed between two abysses, condemned and aware of it; diversion is flight from that thought, the wager the answer to it. Grounding:myslyashchiy-trostnik,dva-beskonechnykh,pari. - Schopenhauer (
schopenhauer) — existence is vain and finite; a sober look at what it costs is the beginning of worldly wisdom, not an occasion for consolations. Grounding:tshcheta-sushchestvovaniya,zhizn-nado-preodolet.
Death is not a subject: unmasking and silence
- La Rochefoucauld (
larochefoucauld) — the sages' "contempt of death" is a pose built by necessity: neither the sun nor death can be looked at steadily. Grounding:prezrenie-k-smerti. - Confucius (
confucius) — while you do not know life, how can you know death? The question is turned back to the duty of the living. Grounding:ming,xiao.
Axis of dispute: Montaigne against La Rochefoucauld — the exercise of dying
against the unmasking of that exercise as a pose; Tolstoy against Epictetus —
death as a question about meaning, not as an object for the training of
judgment.